So last year we decided to drop DISH network. We have had Dish, DirecTV and Comcast (Xfinity). We played the pricing game of changing as the discount expired. We had a Tivo years ago on Comcast (before their DVR) and it worked great. My wife wanted it simple and she really liked using the Tivo.
We watched a Youtube channel called AntennaMan and Tyler ws a great help. He had a service tha speced out exactly what you need for an antenna setup at your location.
As for the DVR, we decided to go with the Tivo Edge for Antenna. It was a great decision. We purchased the all-in subscription for $399 and now with the antenna we get over 80 stations (40 that are worth watching). We can record what we like from the major networks and then be able to watch them later using the "Skip" feature to bypass the ads.
We are saving over $200 a month and with the economy, this has been a blessing. Our only costs after the Antenna ($165 on Amazon that was speced by Tyler the Antenna Man) and Tivo are $50 for Internet (800Mb Cable) and Netflix and Max (HBO). We used the same coax that the cable used to the TVs.
I do wish the OTA Tivo had more tuners for when wife is recording two shows at once, I can't change the channel, but can change to another TV.
All in all we love the Tivo and enjoy it's interface. We have had no issues now for over a year. Great product.

Love my TiVo. I have had one since they first came out. When my previous one died I was afraid I couldn’t get a new one as I heard they were discontinued for antenna. Then you sent me a message that you had one in stock so I am so glad to have one again. The only thing is that it will record 2 programs at once, my old one recorded 4. Anyway very happy with this Tivobedge

First, the customer service people at CM are great. I got my TiVo Edge through the extra effort of one of their team members. Second, the setup/installation was incredibly simple and easy. Third, each step is prompted by separate screens with large lettering, important when it's hard to read the usual small lettering on a lot of products. Fourth, it worked right out of the box. Very happy with my Edge for Antenna.

#1 Wish it had a 1T Drive and behaved better without constant internet connection, but will buy another given a good price opportunity now that I've had months of use to work out many of it's behavioral oddities.

Has decent signal pickup ability/sensitivity somewhere between a CM7000PAL and CM 7500 DVR+

Provides a very good picture on HD captured programming. Even SD captures are quite good too

Have learned that if you turn the unit on after an overnight without internet availability and it gives a blank screen - all I had to do with my 2010 1st generation Samsung "Smart TV" was turn the TV off and back on ... which would sort of kick things and get the TIVO picture displaying on the TV, then it was easy to go through the TIVO menu and do a soft re-boot to get the TIVO to connect to the DSL wireless modem that had been turned off, restoring internet connectivity.

Prior to learning this I was having to do a hard power off wait 10sec and turn power back on to the TIVO and wait for the unit to do a hard re-boot....NOT a good way for things to work 8P

Over all it seems wisest to do a daily soft reboot to keep the box working at peak happiness 8)

I just set up my TIVO Edge and it works great for local channels, which is why I bought it. It is also very user friendly. I do wish that it had more streaming apps options. For example, it doesn't have any of the Disney+, Hulu, ESPN+, Max, or Peacock Plus. The box says it supports Hulu. However, I found out that it doesn't support it anymore.